Immaculate Conception only possible in the Western Church


The doctrine of the Immaculate Conception is only possible in the Western Church that is under the influence of the Augustinian theology of original sin.  
Augustine of Hippo stated that because of the sin of the first people (Adam and Eve) not only the tendency to sin is transmitted to the future generations but also the guilt.  So, people not only are born with the tendency to sin but with the guild of sin that they did not commit yet.   
This teaching only exists in the Churches that are under the Augustinian influence.  The Eastern Orthodox Churches and the Oriental Orthodox Churches did not accept the Augustinian teaching.  For them the guilt is not being transmitted only the tendency.  Therefore Orthodox Churches do not need the dogma of the Immaculate Conception.  For Orthodox Mary was born without the guilt of the original sin but only with the tendency to sin that she rejected throughout her life.   
The Catholic dogma of the Immaculate Conception tries to prove that the person that gave birth to Jesus of Nazareth was perfect since imperfect person cannot give a birth to a perfect person. 

The transmission of the guilt in the Orthodox Churches does not make any sense.  One cannot be guilty of something that one did not do it.  I think, we can make a statement that if there would not be a teaching on transmission of guilt, we would not have a dogma of the Immaculate Conception.   

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ignatian Spirituality

Image
I have been practicing Ignatian Spirituality/Exercises for the last nine years. It has been a powerful experience for me. Each year, practicing that spirituality helps me to go deeper and deeper in my life and relationship with God, the world and myself.  It is just amazing how much they help us to become a more independent person and make better choices for ourselves.  As a person who believes in God I know that God gave me all kinds of gifts.  One of them is my own mind.  I need to use it.  I need to make sure that it is being developed and nourished.  Ignatius wanted us to use that gift.  Also, he wanted us to look and learn from our own feelings and desires.  Sometimes Ignatius of Loyola is called a modern Catholic psychologist. Adlofo Nicolas, the Superior General of the Society gives one of the best explanations of them.   
Read more

The New Peripheries

Image
Another Interview that I found of Bishop Athanasius Schneider.  Bishop Schneider is from Russia but he is of German origin.  He is very much open to discussion and he is very rooted in the Tradition and the Scripture.  I like his way of thinking about: issues of life, ecumenism, liturgy.  I know it is a long interview but very worthy of listening.  Issues of life: saving children are more important than housing and gender equality.  Ecumenism: cannot celebrate a heresy (500 years of Reformation) and unity with Orthodox Christians is very difficult because of the original sin and the question of papacy. With the Orthodox we are of this same faith but papacy.    Bishop Schneider teaches us not to loose faith, hope and charity.  There is a very funny beginning of this interview.  Bishop Schneider - we are on the peripheries of the Church.  It is good to be there with Christ and with you. 
Read more

The Neocatechumenal Way

Image
The Neocatechumenal Way is a Catholic group founded in Spain in 1964 by Kiko Argüello.  It is not a movement but an instrument for evangelization.  It helps people to enter more deeply into the faith experience and share with others this faith experience.   The philosophy of this instrument is based on the early church preparation for non-Jews to become Christians.  It uses some Jewish elements e.g. Eucharist on Saturday evening with the commentaries on readings done by congregation and a presider.   In their spirituality the story of calling of Abraham is in the center.  All the members go on the journey together with him.  We are all called by God like Abraham was.  The question for the people of the Way is: where is my holy land? More on the Way we can learn from their webpage: http://www.camminoneocatecumenale.it/new/default.asp?lang=it
Read more